Differentiating Between Cloud And Virtualization

There’s usually a bit of confusion when people talk about going to the cloud vs. virtualizing. While most cloud providers use virtual machine configurations to optimize their offerings, that’s not the same thing.

As servers and computers increase in compute power and memory. An interesting fact is that virtualizing a computer was first introduced in 1974 by Gerald J. Popek and Robert P. Goldberg (Data scientists) in their article "Formal Requirements for Virtualizable Third Generation Architectures”. However I digress. As Moore’s Law predicted, computers and servers have gotten a lot more powerful, so did the programs running on them need more computer resources. This put a huge burden on equipment rooms, each time a new service or application was added, it required a new server. As the broadcast industry migrated to computer-based systems and services, lots of computers started appearing.

Along Comes Virtualization 21st Century Style

Using the number of processors and cores available in computers, we now have the ability to partition a server assigning segments of the available resources with independent operating systems running different applications in each segment, hence virtualizing the machine. The virtualized machine is still on premise, only now in one physical server there can be multiple virtual servers. This greatly reduces the amount of actual rack real estate, power and HVAC needed in an equipment room for a media server farm. Of course, the broadcast vendors needed to have a version of their product that will run in a virtual environment. There are a number of benefits to running virtual machines. The most obvious one is scaling. If an application running on one VM instance can handle a certain number of users and to add users requires another machine, in the virtual world, it’s just setting up another instance on the same server. There’s no need to purchase a new server or find space for it. Another benefit of virtual machines (VM) is remote access, creating remote gateways and VPN’s using VM’s is more efficient and allows more users remote access. All this is still on premise in main equipment room and the software licenses are pretty much the same as a regular individual server license. Virtualizing the data center is not the cloud.

Moving to the Cloud

OK, so as we have discussed in many articles, the cloud is essentially a remote data center operated by an outside service provider that enables their clients to move their computer/server operations i.e. applications, services and storage off-site to someone else’s facility. Thus saving physical space, environment and hardware maintenance. All this is accessed either via a browser or a local application that integrates to the cloud service. One important note is that most cloud offerings are accessed through an open Internet connection.

An interesting note is that the cloud provider more than likely is running virtual machines in their facility. This allows them to have multiple clients on a single server, which is more efficient to manage and more profitable to the cloud provider. Using a cloud version of an application allows you to set up additional instances or request more CPU or memory for only the time it is needed and not need to purchase anything only rent.

Cloud software is typically accessed either via VPN with some of the application on a local desktop or server or via a browser interface. This changes the configuration of the application from the on premise version to a cloud version. One of the interesting challenges is that not all software is VM ready or compatible, and have different VM versions, now add cloud to the mix and things get complicated.

One of the changes that has come about with cloud offerings is that many broadcast vendors who already moved their products to software only with site licenses are now moving from an on premise installed software version to a cloud based subscription model. This changes a lot of things. On the plus side, the vendor maintains and manages the updates and versions changes, however instead of a capital expense and using the software as longs as you can, it now changes to a subscription model for a monthly fee based on a long term contract. This becomes an annuity for the vendor and difficult to change vendors since all your content is in their cloud. Interoperability between cloud based products is an ongoing work in progress.

In many cases, the user interface of the cloud version is different from the desktop version and in some instances there are different features.

Virtualizing a computer brings a level of efficiency and scalability, migrating to the cloud reduces the amount of hardware on site and changes capital investment to operating expense. In both virtualizing software of moving it to the cloud, there are lots of considerations. 

You might also like...

Software-Defined Automation: Are We Nearly There Yet? Part II

Playout automation has been enabling fewer people to control more channels for decades but we’re not quite at the point where human interaction can be eliminated altogether. Since most linear broadcasters will either move to a software-based deployment for t…

VSF RIST Spec On Road To Wide Implementation

In 2017, at that year’s VidTrans conference a regional gathering of members of the Video Services Forum (VSF), a new protocol for delivering audio and video over lossy IP networks (including the public Internet), was born. It was an idea t…

The Sponsors Perspective: Reaching OTT At Scale - Pitfalls And Opportunities

OTT delivery continues to expand to meet the relentless growing consumer demand. This trend shows no chance of abating and technologists are continually looking to innovation to scale infrastructures accordingly. In this sponsors perspective, Ryan Nicometo, SVP of Product for…

The New Era Of Broadcast - Mezzanine Links And Beyond

20 years ago, broadcast television went through an evolution as it transitioned from analog to digital distribution. This migration was driven by the demand for larger channel counts and spectrum reallocation. Since that transition, another, even more significant sea change has…

Core Insights - Operating An IP Broadcast Facility

Whether we’re routing signals or remotely operating equipment, the need for reliable system control is one of the most important aspects of a broadcast facility. But as we migrate to IP, some of the working practices we took for g…