Broadcast television is undergoing a tectonic revolution from artisanal service provider to industrial scale producer. As the industry moves to its mature phase business owners require a highly efficient production line approach that is scalable, agile and cost predictable, allowing creative production teams to deliver better programming and viewer experiences.
IP is the enabling technology for this revolution, not the reason for it.
Television stations are traditionally rigid, inflexible designs catering for peak transients and worst case scenarios. Flexibility is extremely expensive in SDI. A news operation may only use twenty percent of its resource eighty percent of the time, but when a big news story breaks it’s all hands on deck and the remaining eighty percent can be consumed easily.
Mature Business Attitudes
SDI routers form the core of a TV station with thousands of point to point inputs and outputs. Resilience involves the added expense of buying a second SDI router and either using distribution amplifiers to copy each feed, or providing some sort of vendor specific trunk routing between them.
TV stations do not scale easily. Events such as the Olympics happen every four years and this needs to be catered for at the start of the design. In the life cycle of a station the expensive extra capacity may only be used for five or six months in total.
Highly customized buildings are needed with extra high rooms to cater for deep underfloor cabling. Large power distributions and massive air conditioning systems are needed to keep all the broadcast kit cool.
Broadcast engineers are highly specialized members of the team who have a deep knowledge of their discipline. Unfortunately, they are becoming a rare breed and there are fewer and fewer engineers who truly understand SDI systems.
Regardless of the industry they work in, business managers of mature industries want systems that are highly flexible, cost predictable, resilient and scalable. From a business owners point of view, having to invest in specialist broadcast hardware with all of the costs that are needed to support it is unwelcome and directly affects the productivity of the creative production teams.
Ethernet has been in industry for over forty years, with IP not much behind it. The reliability and resilience of the technology is understood and has stood the test of time. Speeds keep increasing with 25GBASE-T over CAT8 twisted pair cable providing 25Gb/s. And if the cable run is too long then fiber optic could be used instead, further decreasing the physical space taken by the cables.
Six uncompressed 1080p60 (3GB/s) signals with non-blocking switching could travel along a CAT8 25GBASE-T cable. Even better, twisted pair Ethernet cable is bi-directional so can send signals backwards and forwards on one connector, further reducing the cable needed.
Non-blocking Ethernet switches are required to send high data rates
With each 1080p60 source generating 125,000 UDP packets a second the argument for using COTs routers starts to disappear, datacenter grade core switches are needed with 25Gb, 40Gb and even 100Gb interfaces. In reality the network router costs may be as much as an SDI router, but the key to understanding the revolution is not to think about short term savings of hardware, but to think like a business owner of a mature industry and consider the flexibility, agility and predictive costs of an IP network, giving production teams the flexibility needed to improve the viewing experience.
However, the cost of IT equipment is only ever going to decrease as IT sector market forces keep downwards pressure on the price. Broadcasting is a small industry compared to the IT sector but can ride on the back of their savings and technology gains.
Resilience is readily available in IT networking and forms the backbone of its infrastructure. Instead of using centralized SDI routers IT provides distributed routers with high speed fiber trunks connecting them. Studios, graphic areas and edit suites can be treated as data islands with their own routers, meshed in a network with distributed points of failure instead of relying on one SDI router in a control room.
Ethernet and IP infrastructures are scalable by default, and their decentralized hardware philosophy means we no longer have to plan years ahead for SDI router space, power and air conditioning.
OB Back Haul
As well as infrastructure gains, operational benefits soon start to emerge with virtualization of functions. Applications abstract away from the underlying hardware to provide both resilience and flexibility. Typically, four hardware servers could provide ten edit systems. New instances in public clouds such as Azure and AWS are spun up when demand becomes higher than expected, especially as cloud data bandwidth continues to reduce in cost and becomes commoditized.
Virtualization makes much more efficient use of hardware
Back hauling outside broadcast camera and microphone feeds becomes possible as only camera and sound assist crews need to be sent to the event with a small technical support team. Each camera and microphone will have its own IP connection straight back to the studio anywhere in the world. Travel, hotel, overtime and subsistence costs tumble as the majority of production teams and studio crews stay back at the base studio.
Embrace New Paradigm
Skillsets will change as broadcast engineers need to understand Ethernet and IP networks. Instead of being vendor specific product specialists, IT engineers will need to understand timing constraints of video and audio, and software defined networking. Modern software development has a concept of DevOps role, a person who understands the core infrastructure as well as the detailed functions of the applications, this may be how broadcast engineering will evolve.
Technological advances of IP start with the business case, and this time it’s not about saving money in the short term but providing predictable costs, agility and scalability to meet the increasing transient demands of the business. Mature industries such as manufacturing and banking already prove the business case for this philosophy.
The technology will catch up to meet the needs of the business owners, but the real winners will be those who understand, embrace and deliver this new broadcast industry business paradigm.
You might also like...
In the first part of this four-part series we described the basic principles of the Precision Time Protocol. In part two, we investigate PTP redundancy, specifically for media networks.
As the broadcasting industry is moving from a traditional SDI infrastructure towards the All-IP Studio providing a common frequency and – equally important – an absolute notion of time for all devices is now provided by the underlying infrastructure itself. In this fou…
Esports viewership worldwide is on a steep upward trajectory and will soon begin to challenge traditional sports broadcast audience figures. As the esports and traditional sports communities converge, what can traditional broadcasters learn from the remote production workflows being pioneered…
Security is becoming increasingly important for broadcasters looking to transition to IP infrastructures. But creating improved software, firewalls and secure networks is only half the story as cybercriminals look to find new and imaginative methods of compromising data.
At the 2019 IBC convention this year it was clear that the consumer is king and, for broadcasters and content delivery platforms, reliably serving that on-demand ruler with hyper-adaptable operations that can reach many platforms simultaneously could secure the keys to…