How Coax became a VLAN

​There have been many significant changes in the core technologies that make up the infrastructure of the broadcast facility. The cable plant is or was the heart of the broadcast facility. And there are many different types of cables. Now the IP network is the primary backbone and the IP routers and switches play a significant role in media transport, command and control and monitoring. There are many layers within the IP topology. In an SDI environment most of these layers communicate or transport media using different cables and/or fiber optics and are managed by a different type of switching, routing and distribution architecture. In the IP world these layers are known as VLANs (Virtual Local Area Networks) which are segments within the core IP network. Instead of individual cables the IP network can be segmented and each of the different signal types co-exist in the same packet stream using the same routing and switching environment on the same cable and/or fiber. They can do this while being isolated, traveling separately and protected.

The signal handling within the SDI architecture is managed by each signal type having its own cable type. There is some sharing, however the paths and devices that manage the signal flow are unique to the signal. There is SDI video (SD, HD. UltraHD and 4K) with embedded Audio and sometimes data, analog, AES & Madi audio, 2, 4 Wire and VoIP Communications, RS422 & RS485 and IP control and management.  

SignalCableConnector
SDI VideoCoax/fiberBNC/ST
AES/Madi AudioCoax, multi pair/fiberBNC/Phoenix/ST
Analog AudioSingle/Multi PairXLR/Bare end
Machine Control RS422/232Multi ConductorDB9, Phoenix
ManagementCat5/6eRJ45, Punch block
IntercomSingle/Multi PairXLR, DIN
Router ControlCoax/Multi-pair/CAT5/6eBNC/phoenix/RJ45, DB9

In the IP architecture, each of these signals are either encoded to IP or originates as IP at which point it will use the same network cable type (CatxE or Fiber). Also once the signals become IP, they all use a similar type of switch. In the IP architecture the way signals or media types are differentiated and segregated is by individual networks or network segments. It is very cumbersome and inefficient to build separate networks with separate switches and cabling to support each of the signal formats, so instead of using separate switches, a virtual network is created within the network. These Virtual Local Area Networks are more commonly known as VLAN’s. A VLAN is a network segment or partition that is created inside the core network and established as a separate domain.

In the VLAN network topology, the different devices and their signals are connected to the same switches and it is part of the switches responsibility to “groom” the signals together into a single IP stream. The network can be configured with multiple VLAN’s enabling all the different signals and files to co-exist and move about the network infrastructure on the same cable/fibre and using the same switches.

This table shows the how the signals now map to a VLAN, plus there are new VLAN’s that are needed for information or data that did not exist in the SDI architecture.

VLANs replacing cableFormat
Video StreamsMPEGTS, JPEG2000, H.264/5
Video FilesMXF, .mov, .QT, DnX
Audio StreamsMadi, CobraNet
Audio FilesWav, mp3, AIFF, PCM
IntercomVoIP
Command and Controlxml
Machine controlxml
Router controlxml
New VLANS in the IP infrastructure
MetadataText
Media ManagementText, jpg, proxy, application access
KVM transportHigh resolution video, mouse and keyboard

So in essence, each VLAN can be compared to the unique cables previously used for each of the signal types. Now, each of the signals are in the same switch and are groomed into a single IP stream that travels over the same cables/fibers. As it connects to each device on the network, the device understands which VLAN and signal it is taking commands from, whether it is sending or receiving files and what process to execute or what file to manage.

VLAN’s provide support for critical network management such as bandwidth management, latency control, access control and security. Interestingly, the KVM is one of the highest bandwidth users since all nodes receive high resolution video all the time. It is critical to isolate this or it will interfere with media movement and command and control.

VLAN’s are created in the network router and/or switch and the VLAN’s are managed and controlled so that each segment is optimized for the specific signal type or data it will carry. Each VLAN is based on using the primary network addressing structure and creating a unique IP address range per VLAN and specific device addressing under the VLAN address range.

Example

If the main IP network addressing is based on a 10.bbb.ccc.ddd schema, then the first set of numbers or octet 10 identifies the main network address, the second octet bbb is the main network segment, ccc identifies a VLAN and ddd is the specific address for a device. So in this example an server with an address of 10.250.12.25 would indicate it’s main network segment is 250 and is on VLAN 12 and the unique device IP address 25 .

In the table below the range addresses change but there can be many devices with the same last octet address without creating a conflict as long as they are on different VLAN’s.

If we look at mapping a network’s VLANs we might see the following

VLAN DescriptionVLAN rangeDeviceDevice address
Video Streams10.250.10.xxxEncoder10.250.10.25
Audio/ Video Files10.250.12.xxxMAM Server10.250.12.25
Audio Streams10.250.13.xxxMixer10.250.13.25
Intercom10.250.15.xxxIntercom10.250.15.25
Command and Control10.250.16.xxxAutomation10.250.16.25
Router control10.250.18.xxxRouter Matrix10.250.18.25
Metadata10.250.19.xxxMAM10.250.19.25
Media Management10.250.20.xxxStorage10.250.20.25
KVM transport10.250.21.xxxDistributed control10.250.21.25

There are different ways to manage network traffic and the segregation of VLANs. Access Control Lists (ACLs), Trunking and Quality of Service (QoS) are a few.

It’s interesting to view the transition from a physical cable carrying different signals to an IP packet and addressing convention where all the signals can be groomed into a single stream, devices can read and resolve the information or commands based on the address and all within one IP network topology.

Let us know what you think…

Log-in or Register for free to post comments…

You might also like...

OTT - What and Where to Monitor – Part 3

In the last two articles in this series we looked at why we need to monitor in OTT. Then, through analysing a typical OTT distribution chain, we sought to understand where the technical points of demarcation and challenges arise. In…

NAB 2019 – Technology vs Consolidation

Giving his unique view on NAB2019, Gary Olson considers and scrutinizes the big moving trends of consolidations, and casts clarity on the cloud, ATSC 3.0, and AI.

Essential Guide: Immersive Audio Pt 2 - Immersive Audio Compatibility

Immersive audio has the great potential to transform our human listening experience, captivate our imagination, and inspire our inventiveness.

Why We Need OTT Monitoring – Part 2

In the previous article in this series, “Understanding OTT Systems”, we looked at the fundamental differences between unidirectional broadcast and OTT delivery. We investigated the complexity of OTT delivery and observed an insight into the multi-service provider silo culture. In thi…

Data Recording and Transmission: RF

In part 8 of the series “Data transmission and storage”, consultant John Watkinson looks at some of the intricacies of RF transmission.