​How to Quality Control for HDR

What are the impacts of High Dynamic Range on the Quality Control process? Given the confusion in the industry surrounding the different formats, the impact is greater than you’d think and still being worked through. The Broadcast Bridge took the advice of leading QC tools developers.

HDR, of course, all starts with filming in the correct format and flows from there: material needs to be high dynamic range (10-bits is the minimum but realistically 12-bits), wide colour gamut, the right colour transform, and in some cases: provision of data about the display device used for mastering, maximum content lightness level (MaxCLL) and maximum average frame light level (MaxFALL).

In general, the earlier in a workflow you can set-up and check HDR the better. In particular, HDR set-up at acquisition is important and can be complex in situations where there are a mix of cameras with different specifications and characteristics are being used.

Following acquisition, post production offers the next best opportunities to adjust for HDR and color balance.

Some of these parameters can only be calculated when the content is finished (after editing and grading) so the final check for HDR compliance can only be at the end when the file is ready for delivery, as HDR can require that this metadata is inserted into the media file (depending upon the format).

According to Thomas Dove, Director of Technology, QC Products,  Telestream, most people in the broadcast industry have an overall understanding of what HDR means and can recite the buzzwords, “however actual implementation and generation of HDR content is truly understood by very few and there is hardly any HDR content available right now.”

This is for four reasons, believes Dove. Firstly, HDR requires new concepts to be understood - and some aspects of these new concepts are perhaps counterintuitive, particularly during post production (as just one example: increasing overall brightness of a scene may have zero effect on the scene as the display device will limit this).

HDR production is not well understood, he says. “The theory is fine but what are the actual practices that must be adopted on-set for filming and viewing rushes.

Thirdly the post production is actually a lot more complex - it really requires thorough understanding of colour spaces and grading and needs different grades for HDR and SDR.”

Lastly, the tools are just not there yet. Currently there is no single post production software which can be used to take camera footage and produce an HDR compliant output.

“This now requires the use of at least three different software packages just to produce a graded HDR output with the correct metadata, and the most commonly-used NLE software does not provide all the tools required for HDR media file production. There is only one professional monitor feasible to use for HDR grading and this costs well over $30,000; there are only a few software packages that will calculate MaxFALL and MaxCLL (and not the ones that might be expected). This situation will doubtless improve in 6 months time, but this is where we are now.”

Tektronix agrees that there’s a degree of confusion about the various HDR standards and how these interact with the various characteristics of available cameras.

For example, says Ian Valentine, Director Business Development, Video Test at Tektronix, the PQ gamma curve has been used extensively in packaged consumer products (e.g. Blu-ray) and only works with PQ compatible displays. HLG (Hybrid Log-gamma) is used for live production and is Rec. 709 compatible. HLG can be used with a standard display but for best results you’ll need a display that supports HLG.

“Since there are so many HDR standards (HDR10/HLG/PQ/Dolby Vision, etc.) what often becomes critical is the OETF (optical electrical transfer function) which will ultimately govern the appearance of the image on the screen. Multiple OETFs have to be managed in mastering and post production for consistency in color and scene matching where multiple cameras have been used in acquisition. This is an important area of focus for Tektronix.”

Indeed, Tektronix WFM8300 waveform monitors and rasterizers include a series of special HDR graticules that allow users to correctly set camera white points and adjust specular highlights to create stunning looking content.

One of the key graticules is specifically setup for 18% grey (20NITS) and 90% reflective white (100NITS) for easy adjustments to correct grey and white points of content which is essential in HDR application, explains Dove. Other HDR capabilities include support for both SMPTE ST 2084 standard and HLG as per ARIB ST B-67 standard. HDR capabilities can easily be added to the existing WFM / WVR8000 series products with the purchase of Option PROD (a field upgradeable software-only option).

You might also like...

Practical High Dynamic Range (HDR) Broadcast Workflows - Part 2

There is a school of thought that suggests increasing the brightness through the contrast control on a television will give a higher dynamic range. However, this doesn’t necessarily increase the contrast ratio. Quantization noise is the enemy of dynamic r…

Practical High Dynamic Range (HDR) Broadcast Workflows - Part 1

HDR is taking the broadcasting world by storm. The combination of a greater dynamic range and wider color gamut is delivering images that truly bring the immersive experience to home viewers. Vibrant colors and detailed specular highlights build a kind…

Creative Analysis: Part 17 - DOP Simon Rowling On Legacy Of Lies

Some films languish in preproduction hell for years. For cinematographer Simon Rowling, though, only a matter of days elapsed between first discussing Legacy of Lies and flying out to begin location scouting. The production, which stars Scott Adkins as a…

WFH: Tech Choices From Edit To Approval

You have two key choices for remote technologies: those that give you remote access into machines and devices at your facility or those based in the cloud. Depending on your needs it may be sensible to take a mixed approach.

WFH: Baby Steps And Lasting Legacy

Until very recently, the idea that editors and VFX artists could work remotely from one another seemed a far-off reality. Yet, Work From Home measures mean media companies have had to pivot overnight to a remote work setup. Content creation…