Hardware Infrastructure Global Viewpoint – December 2019

IP: Short for Idiot Proof?

IP solutions were top-of-mind at IBC and NAB. The question remains, are they real.

After attending some 75, or so, trade shows, I imagine myself as a decent judge when it comes to a show’s success in advancing any particular technological theme. Some show-announced technological improvements live on for many years, like automation for example.

Other technology show themes die a quick death.

At the turn of the decade, the Consumer Electronics Show (CES) 3D television was all the rage. Millions must have been spent just promoting 3D, let alone developing the televisions. But money spent does not guarantee success.

Anyone recall the main technology theme of NAB back then? It was 3D of course.

Strictly because of the 3D hoopla of the CES show, the following NAB show was all a rush with 3D as the next “must have” television technology. NAB exhibitors did their best to highlight their 3D products and demonstrations.

Did the technology last? Did it succeed? No, 3D died faster than a bug in a bird’s mouth.

Industries have spent hundreds of millions of dollars promoting 3D. Yet to view this image in 3D, you need to build your own 3D glasses. Image courtesy Experimentosparaniños.org

Industries have spent hundreds of millions of dollars promoting 3D. Yet to view this image in 3D, you need to build your own 3D glasses. Image courtesy Experimentosparaniños.org

One must be careful when deciding if any technology exhibited at NAB or IBC will last through the next “idea” from the consumer electronics people.

Five years later,  we come to another IBC. With the above caveat, this year’s IBC had two themes; IP connectivity and High Dynamic Range (HDR) imagery. Let’s examine where the first of these ideas (IP) stands.

Probably 80 percent of the booth visits and press conferences I attended involved some discussion about the vendor having an “IP solution”. The word “compatibility” was less often used.

While the claimed benefits from implementing IP solutions are many, it is far less clear when industry-wide solutions may truly be available. Some tests are underway.

The EBU, VRT (a Flemish public broadcaster) and more than a dozen additional technology partners created the world’s first total IP TV studio. The project uses state-of-the-art IT-centric hardware and software to enable the production of programs.

VRT studio uses IP connectivity to embrace the needs of live TV production.

VRT studio uses IP connectivity to embrace the needs of live TV production.

The multi-phase LiveIP Project is part of Sandbox+, an international joint platform for collaborative innovation put together by VRT, EBU and iMinds. Familiar vendors participating in the project include Axon, Dwesam, EVS, Genelec, Grass Valley, Lawo, LSB, Nevion, Tektronix and Trilogy. A great article about the technological demonstration is here, see this article on The Broadcast Bridge.

A scaled down version of the studio was on display showing a proof-of-concept demonstration on the EBU IBC stand. So, yes, IP does work in a television production environment.

Evertz MAGNUM SDVN orchestration and control software for IP and hybrid facilities powers Evertz' Software Defined Video Networking (SDVN) solutions.

Evertz MAGNUM SDVN orchestration and control software for IP and hybrid facilities powers Evertz' Software Defined Video Networking (SDVN) solutions.

The reality of IP.

With the failure of 3D to develop as a competitive solution, the first test of a new technology is how many vendors are supporting the new idea. But then there were plenty of supporting demonstrations of 3D at the back in 2010 and it eventually died an inglorious death.

Now there are many vendors supporting a move to IP interconnectivity. IBC show announcements included the Evertz ASPEN, a method to encapsulate uncompressed Ultra HD, 3G, HD and SD for transport over an MPEG-2 transport stream. Sony is a partner in using the technology.

Sony and Evertz exhibited the integration of their solutions in live production demonstrations in each other's IBC booths. The demonstrations included MAGNUM, Evertz SDVN Orchestration and Control and Sony's IP Live Production switching Sony NMI over Evertz high capacity switch fabrics.

Evertz says that Ross Video and 12 other vendors and facilities support the protocol.

Ross Video Acquity production switcher.

Ross Video Acquity production switcher.

But, there are other heavy-hitter players in the IP space. Imagine Communications and EVS, announced official cooperation to make their solutions IP compatible.

“With EVS we are aggressively going after the live news and sports market,” declared Imagine Communications CEO. “We are taking their best of breed solutions in slo-motion and instant replay and marrying that with our playout automation.”

Imagine demonstrated their signal processor, Selenio MCP and Magellan SDN Orchestrator software managing multichannel HD video over SDI and IP linked to EVS’ XT3 server and the EVS XiP gateway.

“The key is that we are using SMPTE-2022 standard and our JPEG-2000-based compression to allow broadcasters to work with video over SDI and IP at the same time,” said Vogt.

By putting its weight behind SMPTE and the J2K scheme Imagine expects others to follow. “The evolution of standards will accelerate around successful technologies being deployed by the largest global companies. DirecTV, Disney ABC, Fox Networks are all adopting SMPTE-2022 and J2K so you will see smaller companies begin to adopt those.

Imagine Communications SelenioNext high-density multiscreen transcoder.

Imagine Communications SelenioNext high-density multiscreen transcoder.

Other companies, while supportive of IP solutions, were much less enthusiastic. And, there remains more work to be done in the standards arena. The current SMPTE 2022-6 standard is long way from being as common as SMPTE 259M.

More than one exhibitor compared the current IP solutions as similar to MXF. While many vendors claimed to support MXF, the solutions were often incompatible.

One day IP connectivity will be as common and well understood as SDI. However, just because a company with 45B in revenue adopts some vendor’s solution does not mean everyone can/should do so. Recall also the “Tape is dead” theme when hard drives became available? Tape lives on as an effective and low-cost LTO archive solution.

Technology seldom grows or dies as fast as proponents claim. Follow the money.

IP does not mean Idiot Proof.

Your Thoughts:

This article must be many years old, does not seem fresh in Dec 2019?

January 9th 2020 @ 10:29 by Øyvind Vikanes

Scroll for more comments

Let us know what you think…

Log-in or Register for free to post comments…

Related Editorial Content

From SDI Baseband to IP Routing

While the Television industry has been well served by SDI Baseband technology including routers, coax cable and BNC connectors, new IP-based video/audio infrastructure and workflows are promising far more flexible and cost-effective solutions in the future. However the new…

OTT TV subs to triple in four years

Traditional pay TV providers are struggling to cope with the rapid growth of OTT TV services such as Netflix and Amazon Prime. This increased competition is forcing them to consider unbundling their packages to create competitive, stripped down offerings without…

IBC Awards Foreground Innovation in IP

It is a sign of how far broadcast engineering has come when the IBC 2015 Innovation Awards are dominated by IP technologies. Two thirds of the shortlisted projects commend achievements in remote production or networking using virtualised systems.

Viewpoint: IP, the fast lane to TV everywhere?

It is inevitable, that once content becomes separate from the carrier, a transition that has already taken place, data networks will replace baseband.With the transition to digital essentially complete, we now get to reap the benefits, and havoc, that…

Many Broadcasters Suffer from IP FUD Say Vendors

The shifting behavior of young people — who demand their television programming anywhere, anytime and on any device — is forcing a massive re-invention of broadcast technology and is driving a shift toward viewing over the Internet.