While there was plenty of cloud discussion at IBC, is the technology, at this time, ready for broadcast?
The broadcast industry is talking increasingly about the importance and role of cloud technology. Perhaps a related question should be asked, “Is the cloud ready for prime time?”
When Joni Mitchell concluded the third verse of her much-loved 1967 song “Both Sides Now” (which was, interestingly, a hit for Judy Collins before Mitchell recorded it) with the line “I really don’t know clouds at all.” – she might have been speaking for the broadcast industry in 2016. It seems to me, there’s still a great deal of uncertainty about what cloud technology brings to our table.
For the broadcast industry, the cloud is something of a new phenomenon. It’s an opportunity that has presented itself with the progressive IT-ification of the industry. For the IT industry, it’s long been a fact of life. In fact, you could almost trace its roots back to the time when Joni Mitchell was first making a name for herself, with the availability of RJE (remote job entry) services.
Pay as you go
Why has the cloud become a significant fact of life in the IT industry? There are several reasons. Perhaps first among these is the desire to reduce CAPEX in favour of OPEX. For many companies and organisations, building out huge server farms and data centres in order to accommodate huge increases in data flow and users – not to mention the added burden of accommodating an increasingly Internet-centric world – was becoming unaffordable in capital expenditure. The cloud offered the opportunity to replace that heavy upfront cost with a manageable, predictable operating cost.
Broadcasters may benefit from a lower CAPEX with a cloud solution. Even so, the business calculation involves more than just monthly costs.
A second additional attraction, of course, is that you pay only for what you use. In an ‘owned-server’ model, you have to invest in enough computing capacity to meet peak demand – even if that means, for the majority of the time, your servers may be lying idle to a greater or lesser degree. The cloud delivers flexibility, easy scalability and redundancy.
A third factor is that the cloud also creates a highly secure environment in terms of data integrity. Disk crashes and disaster recovery are, in effect, no longer the concern of the company or organisation: they are simply “taken care of” by the cloud operator.
Businesses realized that running huge rooms full of servers was not their core business – nor, particularly, an area of expertise. Those businesses were, more and more, looking to outsource those activities. After all, businesses outsource other tasks, like catering and cleaning, to companies for whom they were a core competency. Outsourcing non-core activities allowed organisations to focus their efforts on what their business was all about.
Choosing a proper cloud solution is neither straight forward or obvious. Many factors need to be considered before moving content off site.
A fourth reason to consider a cloud solution might be that using a supplier who is in the business of delivering computing services gives you access to expertise, experience, capabilities and resources that are well beyond anything you could – or would want to - develop in-house.
Maybe not today
You’re probably thinking: “All those things – reducing CAPEX, maximising flexibility and security, focusing on my real business and leveraging external expertise – are no less important to me as a broadcaster. I therefore should be thinking about moving towards a cloud-based model for my infrastructure.”
And indeed you should. But, perhaps not today.
Many of us in the broadcast industry believe the cloud is not quite there yet. Why do I say that? Simply, unlike the ‘average’ business, the broadcast business is hugely sensitive to latency. For companies not in the business of distributing high-quality video content, latency is a non-issue. For us, it’s all but a matter of life and death.
The fact remains, with cloud solutions there are various stages at which small amounts of latency are added. Individually, they’re scarcely relevant. Collectively, they make a substantial difference. As things stand, the public network really isn’t designed or equipped to handle traffic that is highly latency-sensitive.
Of course, some organisations have elected to pursue a private cloud strategy, in which they can ‘iron out’ those delays. That is, of course, always an option. But in my mind that somewhat defeats many of the key reasons for choosing cloud in the first place.
It’s important to realise that while the cloud may appeal by virtue of its perceived simplicity, it can add a layer of complexity to the workflow. With in-house servers, you have absolute control over your data within the workflow. A cloud-based paradigm adds a layer of complexity in terms of maintaining that data security. Also, there’s an extent to which deciding to follow a cloud-based model depends on the kind of person or organisation you operate. How comfortable are you handing over ‘control’ of your content to a third party?
I said above that “the cloud is not here yet” for the broadcast industry. “Yet” is the key word. What is true today will be less true tomorrow – and even less true the day after that. It’s also important to note that, for non-latency-sensitive applications, such as OTT, the cloud is today a practical reality.
New cloud solutions continue to be developed. Broadcasters will need to choose the proper time to make a switch.
Cloud solutions will mature
The cloud will increasingly become a viable option for the broadcast industry as the supporting network infrastructure is upgraded, thanks to the accelerating commoditisation of powerful hardware (and the software that turns a platform into a solution – something that we have long been a firm believer in). Moving around 125,000 packets/second isn’t currently achievable with current industry technology. But 10 Gigabit bandwidth is rapidly becoming the norm, and we’re now starting to see the inexpensive 25 Gigabit network products enter the market. There’s no doubt in my mind that those solutions will soon become as commonplace as 1 Gigabit once was. And, the cost of the necessary bandwidth is becoming less prohibitive by the week.
It was apparent at IBC that the industry is gearing itself up for a cloud-based future, with multiple exhibitors offering appropriate solutions. And, indeed, it is the future. That’s one side of the story. The other side is that the operational reality isn’t quite with us today. When considering a cloud solution, the upsides need to be weighed against the downsides.
To finish where I started: “I've looked at clouds from both sides now, From up and down…”
Simen Frostad, Chairman of Bridge Technologies.
You may be interested in other articles by this author (see below).
You might also like...
Artificial Intelligence is more than just one element. In this article, we look at and describe the many parts AI encompasses.
After visiting the recent Henry Stewart DAM (Digital Asset Management) conference in New York, Gary Olson asked some very difficult questions of Cloud vendors regarding security. Their responses may surprise you.
Giving his unique view on NAB2019, Gary Olson considers and scrutinizes the big moving trends of consolidations, and casts clarity on the cloud, ATSC 3.0, and AI.
Moving to IP opens a whole plethora of options for broadcasters. Engineers often speak of the advantages of scalability and flexibility in IP systems. But IP systems take on many flavors, from on-prem to off-prem, private and public cloud. And…
As the IP revolution continues to gain momentum and more broadcast facilities take advantage of the fantastic and unprecedented opportunities IT delivers, administrators and system designers must master the complex aspects of data storage.