Where is Production Technology Headed for 2019? Part 2

This is part 2 of the series “Where is Production Technology Headed for 2019?” Here we ask three executives from key production technology companies for their thoughts on new technology developments for 2019.

As in Part 1, these experts were asked about the post communities' transition to IP production technology in the light of new SMPTE standards, the evolution of post-production over the past few years, and where they felt post was headed for 2019. Part 1 in the series can be found here


Throughout the course of 2018, SMPTE ST 2110 has been a driving “force for increased flexibility in production IP workflows and the impetus behind the modular approach to broadcast media routing,” Bryce Button, director of product marketing at AJA Video Systems started out, “allowing video and audio to be embedded and disembedded separately as needed. 

Bryce Button, director of product marketing at AJA Video Systems.

Bryce Button, director of product marketing at AJA Video Systems.

“New standards within the SMPTE ST 2110 protocol that will continue to evolve in 2019 include SMPTE ST 2110-22, which aims to standardize compression across IP to help conserve bandwidth, and SMPTE ST 2110-31 for transport of AES3 audio, introducing leading audio standards to the evolving broadcast IP delivery system. And AJA has taken full advantage of it.

“We continue to integrate SMPTE ST 2110 standards into our full range of production solutions, including the Thunderbolt 3-equipped Io IP and our IP to/from SDI and HDMI Mini-Converters,” he said. “Looking forward to 2019, we can also expect to see further developments in IP with the auto-discovery process, enabling equipment to self-identify and communicate what it’s capable of transmitting and receiving. PTP timing protocol for synchronizing elements will also continue to develop, allowing master clocks to sync streams for more accurate timing throughout production chains. The result is we can all produce better product.

“The prevalence of HDR and WCG content has also led to the growing modern workflow of using LOG source materials from cameras,” Button continued, “providing a great starting point for extracting the largest dynamic range and color gamuts possible from the source for delivery as P3 or BT 2020 for the various HDR formats, including Dolby Vision, HLG or HDR10. Our FS-HDR converter easily bridges many of these new color spaces and HDR formats, and has become a standard piece of gear in finishing post suites.”

What's ahead for post?

“Pipelines are continuing to evolve,” said Button, “and though designed to be as simple as possible for post professionals to use and navigate, video creatives are expected to understand protocols and approaches more commonly associated with the IT side of the business. It behooves any creative who is making this transition to spend as much of their spare time as possible getting up to speed with these standards, using resources like The Broadcast Bridge to learn about them.”

“Creatives must also be open to a range of new possibilities that have become available as IP becomes more of a standard,” he concluded. “including greater density for routing, more powerful use of metadata and the increasing ability to collaborate within larger shared workgroups. In tandem with this, creatives are quickly embracing single-cable simplicity for SDI workflows with 12G-SDI, allowing large raster, deep color and high frame rate workflows and, in either case, SDI or IP or a combination of the two."


Bill Thompson, product manager - storage products at EditShare, echoed many respondents’ enthusiasm for what SMPTE has been achieving.

Bill Thompson EditShare product manager.

Bill Thompson EditShare product manager.

“First, let’s remember that SMPTE Professional Video over IP delivers these benefits:

  • It can eliminate the need for 2 separate facility networks (one for HD-SDI signals and one for IP/Ethernet) by embedding video signals in IP and delivering in real time.
  • Hard-wired coaxial HD-SDI infrastructure is not software definable. IP networks are both software defined and virtualizable.
  • IP-based networks cost much less to build, install, maintain and upgrade than coaxial-based HD-SDI infrastructure.
  • Moving to Professional Video over IP is consistent with the larger trend in the enterprise space of eliminating specially built and managed dedicated networks in favor of unified corporate networks managed by IT professionals.

These benefits are really valuable for segments like broadcast master control, live production, outside broadcast by virtue of the need to dynamically change signal routing to select inputs, content and destinations.”

Thompson went on to say, “In the post-production space addressed by EditShare, it has been many years since nonlinear, file-based workflows displaced coaxial infrastructures. While the benefits of incorporating SMPTE Professional Video over IP may ultimately make post-production solutions easier to manage and more efficient, challenges like content security and storage costs currently command more customer attention.”

And the major trends Thompson identifies?

Our post production customers tell us that we’ll see major growth in corporate video as companies increase their use of video to get their messages across. As a result, collaborative workflows will demand remote workers, multi-site facilities, content security measures and hybrid (cloud/on-premises) solutions.

“We’ll see more high resolution (4K and beyond), higher dynamic range, and immersive experiences like VR driving performance requirements and associated networking capabilities.

But Thompson recognizes this comes at a price.

“We need to tame equipment costs and system management tasks in current and next-gen products,” he said. “Content owners are becoming acutely aware of the need for safeguards in their own facilities and organization as well as across those within their chain of service providers. In addition, greater use of computer generated effects (outside of blockbuster movies) to differentiate content and reduce production costs is driving storage performance requirements and scalability.”

The best is yet to come.

“When I think about the next 10 years of post production,” he said, “I envision that we will see at least some of the following changes:

  • Wider access to production techniques like VR as technology costs fall.
  • More economical cloud-based solutions for storage, backup and post production tasks.
  • Greater incorporation of content security principles across the post production industry.
  • Emergence of AI-based solutions for tasks that, today, typically require artists and craftspeople.

Brainstorm Multimedia

“Brainstorm is a software company,” began Miguel Churruca, marketing and communications director at Brainstorm Multimedia, “so we are not constrained to specific technologies as we want to take advantage of any new hardware. As a result, when it comes to IP-based production, we welcome the arrival of the SMPTE specifications which clarify the situation.

Miguel Churruca, marketing and communications director at Brainstorm Multimedia.

Miguel Churruca, marketing and communications director at Brainstorm Multimedia.

“Brainstorm has always been dedicated to real time 3D graphics, and we are extremely happy to see technology evolve to comply with many of the objectives we’ve marked in previous years. To accomplish this, traditionally we had to make compromises between feature sets weighed against rendering and operation speed, and the amount of data required for displaying advanced weather graphics has always been an issue.

“Rendering has always been a challenge,” Churruca continued, “both for speed and quality. We can use high-end rendering techniques such as PBR (Physically Based Rendering) along with HDR to create photorealistic results. Also, upcoming GPUs allowing for real time ray tracing and other features will represent a major change in the looks of television graphics. This, also coupled with the use of render engines originally developed for games, is pushing the overall quality of the final graphics and getting them to a new level. Photorealistic backgrounds are now increasingly popular in virtual set operation, and also in AR applications now being widely used by broadcasters.”

Churruca sees the future of graphics as just getting brighter.

“Of course, we must rejoice!” he said. “Now that the toolsets available are huge, usability will be paramount for allowing designers to deliver their best. And as data analysis tools evolve, and link more closely with the graphics applications, we will be able to see more complex but understandable data-driven weather graphics, also creating in-context 3D AR environments which take the concept of the ‘information graphic’ to a new level. Now, couple this with the integration between graphics applications and photorealistic virtual set/AR solutions, and you will have a winning combination for advanced data presentation, where presenters can interact with graphics in real-time, or the audiences can select the statistics they prefer using second screen applications or interactive TV, and much more.

“But taking into account how many ‘must-have’ concepts and trends didn’t make it over the years,” he finished up, “I am quite curious to see which direction broadcast will take.”


Did you interview anyone who isn’t an older, white male for this series? Everyone in this part and the first seems to say basically the same things, with no real innovative ideas. Maybe if you included younger professionals, some who might be women or of color, the broadcast technology industry might actually start leading the development curve again. We’re falling further and further behind IT and other technology industries because we are stuck in this echo chamber of the same voices getting all the attention over and over again.

January 14th 2019 @ 16:38 by Michael Liebman

Mr. Liebman.

Thank you for commenting.

The series of three articles, “Where is Production Technology Headed for 2019?” was never meant to be a collaborative discussion from editing and grading equipment users.  It was, as clearly stated, “….the beginning of a series of articles where thought leaders in the post community share some of their ideas on upcoming 2019 technological developments.”

With NAB 2019 on the horizon, attendees need to know about the kind and direction of technological developments that may be presented on the show floor. Purchasing decisions are based on available equipment and not wishful thinking. This series of articles provides that good background guidance.

Asking the opinion of those not in decision-making positions, or just because they are of a certain gender or race brings no useful purchasing information benefit to the reader.

Do those opinions count? Yes they do, but in a different editorial set of articles.

If you would like to start that focus, I welcome your input.


January 15th 2019 @ 17:24 by Brad Dick Editor
Let us know what you think…

Log-in or Register for free to post comments…

You might also like...

Nine Pitfalls Of Relying On FTP To Move Large Media Files

Broadcasters are continuing to adopt and take advantage of IT working practices as they transition to file-based workflows. However, some seemingly effective solutions are outdated, have not kept pace with advances in computing power, and are unable to efficiently transfer…

Color and Colorimetry – Part 5

In a multi-disciplinary subject such as color space, it is hard to know where to start. John Watkinson argues that the starting point is less important than the destination.

Esports Expands Audiences Using Broadcast IP Production & Distribution – Part 2 – The IP Technology

Esports viewership worldwide is on a steep upward trajectory and will soon begin to challenge traditional sports broadcast audience figures. As the esports and traditional sports communities converge, what can traditional broadcasters learn from the remote production workflows being pioneered…

What Does PCI 4.0 Offer?

When, in May 2019, AMD announced their Ryzen Zen 2 architecture, beyond the amazing performance offered by the new Series 3000 microprocessors, they announced the new chips would support PCI 4.0. Although I was pretty confident the step from 3.0 to 4.0 meant 2X greater bandwidth,…

Esports Expands Audiences Using Broadcast IP Production & Distribution – Part 1 – The Business Case

Esports viewership worldwide is on a steep upward trajectory and will soon begin to challenge traditional sports broadcast audience figures. As the esports and traditional sports communities converge, what can traditional broadcasters learn from the remote production workflows being pioneered…