No memory card manufacturer has ever gotten a complaint about a card being too fast. Today, video cameras continually feature higher resolution and less compression, resulting in the need for cards of greater speed and capacity. It is a game that is constantly changing.
B&H Photo, a major video dealer in New York City, just published a primer on high speed memory of all types. Because memory technology constantly changes, what you knew six months ago may no longer be true.
When memory card manufacturers list their cards’ read and write speeds, B&H notes, they often use terms like “up to” or “maximum” when reporting the spec. A maximum read speed or speed “up to” a certain amount is the maximum burst speed of a card.
It might be able to sustain that speed for a few seconds. But don’t expect to see sustained transfers when you’re shooting video. Sustained transfer speeds can vary greatly from card to card. To determine a memory card's overall speed, just looking at the card's advertised maximum speed isn’t always the best yardstick.
When it comes to storage, solid-state cards are at the forefront for video. But be careful when reading card speeds as video places unique requirements on any storage medium.
It is also important not to confuse bits and bytes. Bits are abbreviated with a lowercase b (as in Mb/s), while bytes are abbreviated with a capital B (MB/s). There are eight bits in one byte. Often, video-recording codecs will list their speeds in bits per second, while cards list their speeds in bytes per second. So, when a video camera records at 400 Mb/s, remember that is “only” 50 MB/s.
Luckily, memory cards have several metrics to help sort out which ones are fast all around. To the uninitiated, B&H noted, they can be a bit overwhelming and look like random numbers. In this article, we will attempt to help the novice understand the differences.
SD versus SDHC versus SDXC Cards
One of the more obvious metrics to consider when comparing SD cards is whether they are SD, SDHC or SDXC cards. While these cards look the same, the file format they use is different, which determines the maximum capacity of the card.
Plain SD cards have a maximum capacity of 2GB, while SDHC cards max out at 32GB and SDXC cards can support up to 2TB — though we aren’t there quite yet. This metric does not affect speed at all; an SDHC card can be just as fast as a SDXC card.
Some SD cards have UHS (Ultra High Speed) Classifications. A UHS (Ultra High Speed) Classification commutates a card’s bus speed, or the maximum speed at which a memory card is capable of transferring data. A UHS classification doesn’t affect the speed of the memory in the card, but manufacturers will rarely make a UHS-I card that is unable to read or write faster than a non-UHS card.
Non-UHS SD cards max out at 25 MB/s, but UHS cards can work much faster. Currently, there are two types of UHS classifications: UHS-I Cards, which have a maximum theoretical speed of 104 MB/s and UHS-II cards that allow for a maximum transfer speed of 312 MB/s.
Note the difference in speeds of these three types of solid-state storage cards. When shooting video, the storage medium must be able to record at a sufficiently high sustained rate. A card's burst speed is not a good measurement of how it will perform with high bit-rate video. Click to enlarge.
UHS-II cards also have a second row of electrical contacts to aid in the speed boost. If your memory card reader or camera does not have the second row of contacts, the speed will be more in line with UHS-I cards.
Because card manufacturers typically only give burst read and write speeds instead of sustained speeds, it can be difficult to pick out a card for other uses than burst photography. Many new 4K-capable cameras write at very high bit rates, and if you plan on recording video for longer than a few seconds, the burst speed doesn’t help much.
Also, there can be a huge variation between the maximum burst read speeds and the minimum sustained write speeds of different cards. It’s not a simple ratio. To determine the minimum write speed of a card, one needs to look at its speed class rating.
A speed class rating means that the card has been verified to never write slower than whatever its class. Some cards may write faster, since the fastest speed class is currently 90 MB/s, but you can be comfortable knowing that any card with a speed class rating will never write slower than that speed.
Remember there are eight bits in one byte, so 30 MB/s is 240 Mb/s. Some popular speed class ratings used on SD cards today are: V90: Minimum 90 MB/s Write, V30: Minimum 30 MB/s Write, U3: Minimum 30 MB/s Write, V10: Minimum 10 MB/s Write, U1: Minimum 10 MB/s Write, Class 10: Minimum 10 MB/s Write, V6: Minimum 6 MB/s Write, Class 6: Minimum 6 MB/s Write and Class 4: Minimum 4 MB/s Write.
Now, that the technical jargon has been decoded, it should be clear that the fastest SD cards available are UHS-II cards with a V90 rating.
The Fastest microSD Cards
MicroSD cards are essentially miniaturized SD cards, and share the same UHS and speed class properties as their full-sized brethren. Like full size SD cards, the fastest microSD cards would be UHS-II V90. That is, if any such microSD card existed. MicroSD cards tend to be a little slower than full-size cards, and currently the fastest microSD cards are UHS-II V60 cards.
However, UHS-II microSD cards are still relatively new, and many microSD-compatible devices don’t have UHS-II capable card readers able to take advantage of the fast speeds offered by UHS-II. If that’s the case, UHS-I U3-rated cards are also worth a look.
CompactFlash cards used to be the faster and more professional big brother of SD cards. That’s no longer true. Several years ago, the CompactFlash Association announced there would be no more updates to the format, leaving card performance with a glass ceiling. Today, CompactFlash cards have hit their performance ceiling, and are about half the speed of the fastest SD cards. The UDMA 7 interface has a maximum possible transfer speed of 167 MB/s, and even if a card manufacturer put faster flash memory in a UDMA 7 card, it wouldn’t matter.
XQD Cards are the reason CompactFlash cards aren’t getting a speed update, because they are the CompactFlash Association’s official replacement for CompactFlash cards. XQD cards are based on the PCIe standard (with an eight Gb/s bus speed), offer far higher maximum transfer speeds than CompactFlash, are much smaller and have a more rugged build than SD cards.
There are currently two versions of XQD cards, Version 1.0, which allows for maximum transfer rates of 500 MB/s, and Version 2.0, which allows for speeds up to 1000 MB/s. While still limited in use, both versions offer faster possible transfer rates than the fastest CF or SD cards available.
CFast 2.0 Cards
Even though CFast cards look almost identical to CompactFlash cards, they are a completely different standard, and will not work in CompactFlash card slots or devices. They are not backed by the CompactFlash association, but are beginning to pick up some steam due to the slow adoption of XQD cards.
CFast Cards use SATA connectors to interface with computers and cameras, and the new CFast 2.0 cards use SATA III, meaning they allow for the same maximum transfer rate of 6 Gb/s (750 MB/s) as SATA III drives. While the interface isn’t quite as fast as XQD 2.0, there still aren’t any cards in either format that come close to the maximum possible speed.
CFast cards are available in capacities ranging from 64GB to 256GB and all feature fast read and write speeds, with the fastest read speeds of 560 MB/s and the the fastest write speed of 495 MB/s.
Memory storage is a rapidly changing technology with manufacturers constantly upping the speed and capacity of the various formats. Expect this trend to continue as video cameras develop greater resolution to 8K and beyond while placing ever increasing demands on storage media.
You might also like...
At one time the only repeatable source of light on Earth was the sun. Later it was found that if bodies were made hot enough, they would radiate light. Any treatment of illumination has to start with the radiation from…
Giving his unique view on NAB2019, Gary Olson considers and scrutinizes the big moving trends of consolidations, and casts clarity on the cloud, ATSC 3.0, and AI.
In part 8 of the series “Data transmission and storage”, consultant John Watkinson looks at some of the intricacies of RF transmission.
As the myriad of live competition television shows continue to attract new and ever larger audiences for TV networks, producing them live has become so complicated that a second technical director (TD), often called a “screens TD,” is now often bei…
When a company markets two products that seem similar, both targeting much the same task, but one costs significantly less, it’s reasonable to assume the less expensive product will offer significantly fewer features.