2018 NAB Show Event Channel

The #1 source of technology content in the broadcast & media industry, by the editors of The Broadcast Bridge - filtered by category.

Click here

Spectre, Meltdown and Broadcasters

The news of the potential vulnerability of processors to attack is just the latest discovery in a long line of vulnerabilities of networked computer systems. It is a salutary reminder of the game of whack-a-mole that systems administrators have to play in order to protect computer networks. Coming at a time when broadcasters are embracing software applications running on commercial-off-the-shelf systems (COTS) and outsourcing to cloud service providers, it reinforces the need for continuing vigilance to ensure business continuity and to avoid the theft of media files.

Engineering is always a compromise, in this case the advantages of networked systems versus absolutely secure systems. There is balance between the cost of security and the business benefits of connected systems.

At one time computer system were isolated; there was an air gap between them and the outside world. An edit controller was a hub, connected via RS422 data connection to tape decks, a CG, a switcher and disk stores. It was a bounded system, it had no external data connections.

In the newsroom environment, it became necessary to offer internet access to journalists as a basic tool for research, email as well is essential. The news editing workstations can be run on a separate media network, but often systems are combined with techniques like virtual machines that allow editing and web browsing on the same workstation. Network firewalls provide the protection.

In the playout environment, COTS equipment has taken over in a networked environment that supports the traffic flows of ads and program file from storage to air servers. Again, such system can be bounded, but the need to load playlists and retrieve logs often require networks access.

Command and control has become much easier with supervisory systems that monitor the health of system components. Such systems are now considered essential to pre-empt and manage faults.

As we move from SDI to IP as the means to interconnect video and audio systems, we lose the security of SDI, point-to-point connections that don’t provide an entry point for hackers.

Hardware vulnerability

Spectre and Meltdown present a different problem from general security vulnerabilities. When the weakness in in the code, and fix can be implemented with a software update. When the vulnerability lies in the hardware design, inside the CPU, it becomes more difficult to resolve without swapping out the hardware once an new hardened design comes along. The fix for Spectre and Meltdown is being implemented in the operating systems, but the downside is that it may impact on performance in some applications.

As broadcaster move from specialized hardware to software apps running on generic COTS equipment in data centers, this hit on performance is going to mean either using more processor cores or taking more processor time. Running cloud apps means bigger bills, using more hardware means increased CAPEX. This cost hit has to be factored into the spreadsheets when designing new systems. Realistically it is going to be a year or more before these vulnerabilities can be designed out of processors, so in the meantime it is an unwanted cost to bear, how much is not yet known.

Awaiting the benchmarks

Right now, I’m sure systems administrators will be running benchmarks and monitoring performance. Apps that use GPU acceleration are going to be OK, those products that run on the CPU only are more at risk. With performance hit of 5 to 30% being quoted, this is not good news. The actual values are more likely to be the lower numbers with 30% being a worst case. The next month or so should reveal the real impact.

Old school engineers will remember the days when equipment had no microprocessors, let alone the replacement of hardware processes with software running on regular COTS servers. However, those days are long gone, modern systems have too many business advantages. The down side is the need for constant vigilance and preemptive security measures, today’s cost of doing business.

Let us know what you think…

Log-in or Register for free to post comments…

You might also like...

Broadcast for IT - Part 6 - Counting Time in 59.94

In this series of articles, we will explain broadcasting for IT engineers. Television is an illusion, there are no moving pictures and todays broadcast formats are heavily dependent on decisions engineers made in the 1930’s and 1940’s. In this article we …

Articles You May Have Missed – March 14, 2018

Two newer technologies are developing that may affect broadcasters, 5G cellular delivery and artificial intelligence (AI). Some experts believe that 5G may develop into a competent OTA program delivery system. Others see 5G as merely another step in boosting cellular…

IP and Software-based Broadcasting Infrastructures: Fact vs. Fiction

IP’s suitability for live broadcasting is no longer debatable. It’s been proven in a variety of real-world global deployments over the past several years. Even so, there’s lingering skepticism around IP and a surprising lack of understanding.

Broadcast for IT - Part 5 - PAL Line and Frame Relationships

In this series of articles, we will explain broadcasting for IT engineers. Television is an illusion, there are no moving pictures and todays broadcast formats are heavily dependent on decisions engineers made in the 1930’s and 1940’s. In the last art…

Audio Over IP - Why It Is Essential

The impact of IP on the design of broadcast equipment and infrastructures is profound. Many broadcasters are replacing existing analog, AES3, MADI and SDI ports with a new class of interface for connecting to standard IT switch infrastructure, together with…